A casebook, folklorist alan dundes brings together a diverse array of writing on this maledominated ritual. In 1958, geertz began an anthropological study of bali, sponsored by the balinese government itself, and after many difficulties, he manages to access the balinese society through a longstanding illegal tradition. Shortly after the election, i taught notes on a balinese cockfight to my anthropological theory class, as i always do, at that point in the. Geertzs thick description and a balinese temple ritual the odalan article. The history of raising fowl for fighting goes back 6,000 years. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Notes on the balinese cockfight is written by a well respected anthropologist by the name of clifford geertz, who details his observations of the balinese culture.
Usually matches vary depending of the bets cast by the audience. The celebrated and controversial essay on the balinese cock fight is defended against its critics, and in an extended conclusion, his account of the balinese theatrestate is, as geertz suggests, proposed as a more adequate method for the combined study of culture and politics than the professionals routine application of heavyhanded concepts. Preface when an anthropologist, urged on by an attentive publisher, begins to gather together certain of his essays for a kind of retrospective exhibi. In the case of the balinese cockfight, a deep fight is one in which results are unpredictable, the odds are more even and the bets are more balanced.
Roosterish imagery is not uncommon cock means hero, warrior, champion, man of parts, lady killer, tough guy etc. Every new intellectual movement needs to look back from time to time. Critique of clifford geertzs research methods in deep play. The continued popularity of this piece is due in no small part to geertzs fluid prose, sharp observation, and selfdepreciating humor. Originating more than 2500 years ago, cockfighting is one of the oldest documented sports in the world. The aim of anthropology is the focus on all aspects of human physical, social, and cultural life and is illustrated in clifford geertz. He even notes that the wordplay where a cock is both a rooster and a penis exists in balinese just as it does in. Sabung, the word for cock and one which appears in inscriptions as early as a. This insight shows how intimate the balinese can be by the morning after the. Notes on the balinese cockfight is an essay included in the book the interpretation of cultures by anthropologist clifford geertz. Geertz is therefore as much as an objective observer as one could be, a fact. In the late days of june of 2011, i arrived in bali, indonesia excited yet diffident. The first documented use of the word gamecock, denoting use of the cock as to a game, a sport, pastime or entertainment, was recorded in 1634, after the term cock of the game used by george wilson, in the earliest known book on the. A cock fight usually consists of two cocks who are equipped with blades and furiously fight till one is dead.
Notes on the balinese cockfight the raid early in april of 1958, my wife and i arrived, malarial and diffident, in a balinese village we intended, as anthropologists, to study. Notes on the balinese cockfight is one of clifford geertzs most influential articles which illustrates not only the meaning of a given cultural phenomenon, the balinese cockfight, but also geertzs interpretative approach that cokcfight a culture as a set of texts to be read by the anthropologist. Pdf on jan 1, 2019, parikshit chakraborty and others published cock fight. Balinese cockfighting observable behavior is the pivot upon which symbolic interactionism revolves around. Clifford geertz is an interpretative anthropologist who believes cultures are symbolic systems consisting of practices which create shared cultural meanings morgan, 2011. Tajen a sensory ethnography on the balinese cockfight. This paper compares and contrasts a marxian materialist approach with a symbolic interpretive approach to describing geertzs cockfight from deep play. Notes on the balinese cockfight in the interpretation of cultures pages 412453 from the vantage of its participants and its spectators. A small place, about five hundred people, and relatively remote, it was its own world. Roseberry 1982 balinese cockfights and the seduction of anthropol. In his article, clifford geertz explores the balinese society through a central element of its cultural life cockfight, seen from the perspective of the outsider who has to prove his loyalty before being acknowledged as a physical presence. Thus, rather than seeing balinese men betting unreasonable amounts of money on a mere game, geertz portrays what appears as play to be a deadly serious struggle over relative status. What can happen to someone who is caught engaging in cockfighting.
For it is only apparently cocks that are fighting there. In his essay, he attempts to give insights on the balinese culture and mainly focusing on the significance of balinese cockfights within the balinese culture. A graduate student entering my second year of study i was anxious for the opportunity to venture out of the books and try my. Geertz was a professor at princeton and received his ph. The cock fight contains two different expressive filters. Notes on the balinese cockfight in the interpretation of cultures, ny basic books. The anthropologist clifford geertzs influential method for the interpretation of other cultures was what we termed thick description. Get essay bentham argues against the betting, as he believes it to be irrational, geertz counters this argument by suggesting people do irrational things the whole time and that it doesnt matter because the important. To move things along, spurs called tadji are attached to one leg of each rooster. The fight, however, was over in a heartbeat as one of the roosters cowered backwards, the blade never even needing to be used.
We approached a gated area where a crowd of balinese men were gathered. Considered geertzs most seminal work, the essay addresses the meaning of cockfighting in balinese culture. Balinese cockfights introduction the dutch banned cockfighting in indonesia. Notes on the balinese cockfight by clifford geertz is available. We were intruders, professional ones, and the villagers dealt with us as. On 1 april 1971 president suharto also declared gambling illegal, which is in line with islamic teaching. Roseberry 1982 balinese cockfights and the seduction. Notes on the balinese cockfight is one of clifford geertzs most influential articles which illustrates not only the meaning of a given cultural phenomenon, the balinese cockfight, but also geertzs interpretative approach that sees a culture as a set of texts to be read by the anthropologist. Critique of clifford geertzs research methods in deep. It has continued to flourish despite bans against it in many countries.
Perhaps one of the most widely read anthropological essays, deep play. Notes on the balinese cockfight 412 acknowledgments 455 index 457. If you have to write a paper or something about balinese cockfight, do not use this as a source. Balinese cockfight pdf perhaps one of the most widely read anthropological essays, deep play. The balinese cockfight is an interesting social and cultural event that has many undertones. Geertz notes balinese cockfight pdf clifford geertz. The flow of blood find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The fight usually ends when this 4 to 5inch sword cuts deep into the loser. For geertz, cockfighting in bali engages central cultural values such as honor, dignity, and respect. Of the theories set forth by kendell blanchard, cultural materialism is perhaps, the most relevant theory and offers the best explanation of the balinese cockfight. In this video, i take an introduction to geertzs thought.
Notes on the balinese cockfight by clifford geertz is available online in standard html format, as well as a pdf file. To make things interesting the balinese make the center bet as large as possible so theres more in stake. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. But it is a momentary gain or lost, the statues is only gained or lost momentarily following the fight but is maintained in the long run, with cockfights assisting in making sure of that. Deep play notes on the balinese cockfight pdf deep play. Early in april of, my wife and i arrived, malarial and diffident, in a balinese.
Court trials, political contests, street arguments are all viewed as cockfights the country itself is even viewed with the imagery of a cock. But it also behooves us to think about the consequences in the material reality of such alignment between substance and symbol, cock and cock, man and ideology, trump and the patriarchy. Vivid descriptions of cockfights from puerto rico, tahiti, ireland, spain, brazil, and the. The language of everyday moralism is shot through, on the male side of it, with roosterish imagery. Shot in the arid landscape of west bali, indonesia, tajen, balinese for cockfight, follows multiple narrative threads of this ancient spectacle that of the blade, the rooster, the cockfighter. Clifford geertz deep play notes on the balinese cockfight. No blood was spilt in this fight, but the losing rooster ended up as dinner for the winning.
Notes on the balinese cockfight, updated on november 29, 2011. By doing so i hope to show the limitations of each of these. Last year a balinese man was actually killed when one of the spurs from the cock slashed him and he bled to death. Conflicted realities in postconflict bali balinese cock precockfight. Ever since clifford geertz 1973 first published deep play. It is the moment when these elements come together during the bloody match that the real drama begins. The independent indonesian government also banned it except in bali, but only for certain purposes. March 5, 2020 admin marketing leave a comment on balinese cockfight pdf.
1177 401 379 436 625 579 1403 111 1415 425 765 976 549 369 1453 1381 611 955 827 729 492 1015 827 603 747 1355 682 308 540 215 1150 212 36 367 617 45 1238 594 1418 493 344 886 973 957 1178 946 688 844 859